Dolls of the Shogun's Harem: Orig. Version vs Int. Version

Film Reviews and Release Comparisons
Post Reply
User avatar
HungFist
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 11917
Joined: 14 Dec 2005, 15:50
Location: Japan
Contact:

Dolls of the Shogun's Harem: Orig. Version vs Int. Version

Post by HungFist »

Two versions of this 1986 Norifumi Suzuki film (reviewed here) exist. The original Japanese cut runs 115 minutes (available on Toei dvd). The English subbed HK laserdisc runs approx 98 minutes and is a complete mess. Here are the changes that I noticed. Spoilers ahead.

1. Missing the Toei logo and short piece of music from the beginning

Image

2. The scene introducing the main characters and some of the harem’s customs has been deleted.

Image

Image

Image

3. The great outdoor festival scene is missing in its entirety. A real shame, as it also features a great song.

Image

Image

Image

4. Osumi’s escape scene has been shortened. We no longer see how she got out from the castle.

Image

5. The dialogue scene between Yoshino and the shogun looses approx 70 seconds of footage.

Image

6. Missing a short scene of Genshiro returning home after work.

Image

Image

7. Missing a scene showing that Onatsu has gained a new position under the new shogun.

Image

8. Dialogue scene between Genshiro and Osumi just before the final scenes has been removed. This leads to severe continuety problems. The first few seconds of the next scene (at the beach) are also missing.

Image

9. The final insult: they’ve deleted the final scene taking place at the beach. This is beautiful scene with a great song. Not to mention there’s a plot twist. Idiots.

Image

Image

Here’s the irony; the original version suffers from overlength. A HK distributor picks the film and decides to fix it by removing the film’s best scenes, plus story and characterization to the point of making it incomprehensible. Brilliant.
Post Reply