Page 1 of 1

Pat Garrett & Billy The Kid -R1 SE v R2UK SE (both cuts)

Posted: 14 Jan 2007, 07:14
by EvaUnit02
Pat Garrett & Billy The Kid - R1 SE vs. R2UK SE (both cuts)

R2UK is cut, R1 is uncut - the choice is simple.

# R1 SE America - (Warner Bros Home Entertainment) - No cuts, two versions of the film.
...
# R2 SE United Kingdom - (Warner Bros Home Entertainment) - Yes:
*1988 Turner preview version = cut by 16s - images of cock-fighting and a horsefall.
*2005 special edition version = cut by 14s - cock-fighting and a forwards horse fall.

(source= dvdcompare)

1988 DC:-

R1 SE
Image

R2UK SE
Image

R1 SE
Image

R2UK SE
Image

R1 SE
Image

R2UK SE
Image

R1 SE
Image

R2UK SE
Image

2005 fan edit:-


R1 SE
Image

R2UK SE
Image

R1 SE
Image

R2UK SE
Image

R1 SE
Image

R2UK SE
Image

R1 SE
Image

R2UK SE
Image

Posted: 14 Jan 2007, 14:05
by bradavon
From a purely PQ point of view I'd say the UK R2 looks just a touch better. I'd get the R1 except I picked the UK R2 up dirt cheap so am happy with it.

Posted: 14 Jan 2007, 14:16
by EvaUnit02
bradavon wrote:From a purely PQ point of view I'd say the UK R2 looks just a touch better.
They look exactly the same to me.

Posted: 14 Jan 2007, 14:35
by bradavon
The R1 looks just a touch to dark.

Posted: 14 Jan 2007, 15:17
by tom2681
@Brad:
You have a LCD monitor, don't you ? :lol:

That's why you always say that the top cap is darker than the bottom cap.

Posted: 14 Jan 2007, 18:41
by Markgway
tom2681 wrote:@Brad:
You have a LCD monitor, don't you ? :lol:

That's why you always say that the top cap is darker than the bottom cap.
:lol: