Now whilst I have little sympathy for fat people and some of the people you see on Gillian Mckeith's show are downright disgusting... I also find Gillian Mckeith's hardcore nutritionist approach ridiculously extreme.
I don't think focusing so much on health and nutrition is overly beneficial for your looks and figure - I mean look at her! Her look, figure and complexion aren't particularly attractive. She's really shrivelled.
Also some of her recipies sound pretty rank. I eat quite healthily but ultimately, it all comes down to maintaining a good balance. And get plenty of exercise obviously.
Also I know it's all staged but her random nitpicking at strangers on that bride/wedding dress show was quite annoying. I wish somebody fought back - maybe they did but didn't show?
I have some sympathy for fat people - OK I know some should get some exercise But what about others with eating disorders, who overeat/comfort eat, or have messed up metabolism so they never feel full. They need help and medication, not ridicule. The same goes for those with anorexia, or the ones who are dangerously slim. It's interesting I've never seen any really skinny people on the show, only "fat" people as Bisc puts it.