The Quick DVD-Review thread

Film Reviews and Release Comparisons
tom2681
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 5577
Joined: 25 Oct 2004, 15:18
Location: Where you'll never find me

The Quick DVD-Review thread

Post by tom2681 »

In this thread, you can post your very own DVD reviews.
As long as they meet some of the following requirements, I will include them in the database below.
P.S: Only one review per post, please.

The average review should include:

[Film Title] (Country of origin - Year of release) - [Region and Distributor]
[Precise running time] (Format (NTSC or PAL))
[Precise aspect ratio][Interlaced/Progressive][Anamorphic/Letterboxed]
[Some comments about overall video quality]
Last edited by tom2681 on 14 Jun 2008, 12:43, edited 11 times in total.
I used to be "the man who loves the movies you hate".
Now I'm just "that weird french guy with a cat avatar who comes to BnB once a year for no reason and then disappears again".
tom2681
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 5577
Joined: 25 Oct 2004, 15:18
Location: Where you'll never find me

Post by tom2681 »

My Tutor Friend (Korea - 2003) - R3HK Edko
113:26 Mins (NTSC)
1.85:1 Interlaced Anamorphic transfer.

The video:
A typical Edko transfer. Interlaced, but anamorphic and reasonably sharp, with nicely saturated colours.
There's some visible print damage, though. White specks and scratches can be seen in every single shot, but thankfully it's not distracting.
Edge-enhancement is kept to a minimum.
Overall, a solid effort. Too bad it's not progressive.

The sound:
You've got 3 flavours to choose from:
- half-rate DTS 6.1 ES Korean track.
- DDEX 5.1 Korean track.
- DDEX 5.1 Cantonese dub.

I only tried the Korean DTS track. The music might be a bit too loud compared to the dialogue and the foley effects, but everything sounds very clear and there are no noticeable A/V sync issues.
There is a slight drop early in the film, which I assume is just a poorly-placed layer break.

The subtitles:
If the Edko release has an Achille's heel, it must be the subs.
They are easy to read and easy to follow, and don't suffer from any major grammatical or spelling errors.
The problem is that they're dubtitles.
The subtitles on this release are based on the cantonese dub, which means that pretty much every line is either inaccurate or out of sync with the korean track.
The problem is both noticeable and irritating, especially since one important plot point is completely mistranslated.

The extras:
- 01.53: Trailer for My Tutor Friend (subtitled both in english and chinese).
- 03.06: A short featurette (chinese subs only).
- 07.34: Interview with the director (removable chinese subs only).
- 03.00: Interview with Kim Ha-Neul (removable chinese subs only).
- 00.25: Two cantonese TV Spots.
- 01.40: Trailer for Crazy First Love (subtitled both in english and chinese).
I used to be "the man who loves the movies you hate".
Now I'm just "that weird french guy with a cat avatar who comes to BnB once a year for no reason and then disappears again".
User avatar
captainjoe
King of Beggars
Posts: 667
Joined: 24 Jul 2006, 00:46
Location: Alberta, Canada

Post by captainjoe »

The Fifth Element

Remastered Blu-ray
Image


(USA - 1997) - R1 Sony Pictures Blu-ray
126 minutes (NTSC)
2.35:1 16x9 Progressive
1080P




Specs:

- Full 1080p High Definition Widescreen 16x9
- 5.1 Dolby TrueHD
- 5.1 PCM uncompressed
- 5.1 French
- Pop-up menus
- Scene Slections
- English Subtitles
- French subtitles
- Chinese subtitles
- Portuguese subtitles
- Spanish subtitles
- Thai subtitles
- Feature-length trivia fact track


Video

This is an unofficial second outting for The Fifth Element on Blu-ray Disc. The original BD was one of the first released. The problem was the print used was in terrible condition with tons of dirt and scratches. Not to mention it looked only slightly better than an up-converted DVD. Now the movie has been restored and all I can say is "perfect!" I have never seen a movie look this good before. King Kong also reaches these heights of perfection. Presented in AVC/MPEG-4, which is different from the original's MPEG-2, this disc reaches up to 40 MBPS during fast motion scenes. Even the end credit sequence was encoded around 17 MBPS. There are no problems at all with this transfer. There is zero dirt and colour is spot on. Every frame pops with detail and it definately has that 3-D look only high definition can provide. I don't think The Fifth Element can look better on Blu-ray Disc. I am very impressed with this release. The Fifth Element has, once again, gained it's status as an excellent "showcase movie."


Audio

Same can be said for audio. Not only do we get a lossless PCM track, but we also get a lossless True-HD track, a first if I'm not mistaken. The original disc only had the PCM track. During the running time, I was totally immersed in the film. Rears are used quite a lot during the gun-battles with Korbin against the aliens. The end credit song provides your sound system quite a work out also, there's a lot of good surround usage and it is perfectly seperated. The scene when Leeloo escapes and dives off the building is perfect demo material as the music provides a lot of bass and crispness. Dialogue is perfect as everything is heard and is placed in the approriate channels. This is one of the best soundtracks I've ever heard.


Subtitles/Captions

The English subtitles seemed to be pretty right on the money in regards to accuracy. I saw no spelling errors of any kind and the font of the titles was appropriately sized. The dubs provided are:
- French subtitles
- Chinese subtitles
- Portuguese subtitles
- Spanish subtitles
- Thai subtitles

Not being fluent in any of these languages I can't tell you whether or not they are an accurate translation. The font is the same as the English captions


Extras

So this is where the disc falls short. Even though this disc has 50 gigs of space, we only get the trivia track. We miss out on all the documentaries from the 2nd disc of the Ultimate Edition DVD. Too bad but I guess it leaves more space for the movie to perform.


Final Thoughts

The movie's great. It's an epic feature that takes the viewer on a wild ride to a future world full of quirky characters, action and wonderful visuals. Not only that but we get a decent plot! The new Remastered Blu-ray is definately one to get when starting out in the world of HD. Never have I seen a disc present a film in such a wonderful way. Just make sure to look for the Dolby TrueHD logo on the back so you don't get the inferior Blu-ray Disc.

Blu-ray Disc
Video: 10/10
Audio: 10/10
Extras: 3/10
Image
User avatar
captainjoe
King of Beggars
Posts: 667
Joined: 24 Jul 2006, 00:46
Location: Alberta, Canada

Post by captainjoe »

FROM BEYOND



Image




Specs:

- 480p Standard Definition Widescreen 16x9
- 2.0 Dolby surround
- Scene Slections
- English Subtitles
- Spanish subtitles
- Audio Commentary by Stuart Gordon and Cast
- Interview with Stuart Gordon
- Restoration featurette
- Interview with Richard Band
- Photo Montage
- Storyboard-to-film



Video

For this incarnation of From Beyond on DVD, MGM has re-inserted new footage originally cut by the MPAA. These cut scenes are great to finally have; there's a lot of gore and
violence that fans can finally see. These scenes are extended shots added on to existing shots so one might see a slight jump in quality between the original shots and the new footage,
but these jumps can go unnoticable. Aside from these slight problems this is a fantastic transfer. Very few DVDs reach this level of excellence, especially ones of this age.
Imperfections are non-existant and natural film grain is present. Being a highly colorful film, color reproduction is a must for this film and luckily they all look glorious! The infamous
pink/red tints really pop and sparkle. This transfer can only be better by a full 1080P HD transfer, cross your fingers!




Audio

Audio is provided in the original 2.0 Dolby surround and while not as striking as the video transfer, it still gets the job done. I'm sure From Beyond could have benefitted
from a new remix but this surround track is decent enough for the film. It has no major defects and is quite clear.




Subtitles/Captions

English and Spanish subtitles are provided and are pretty much accurate to the dialogue but I can't say the same for the Spanish dub because I don't read or speak Spanish. I took a class once but that didn't work out.




Extras




Commentary:

This commentary with Stuart Gordon, Jeffrey Combs and Barbara Crampton is just as great as the one found on the Re-animator Special edition. The three sit back and enjoy recollecting on the production of the film, the final outcome and the Gordon makes sure to point out the newly added footage. The trio get along really quite well and are obviously quite found of each other. Jeff is sure to make some jokes when Crampton's famous scene comes up, you know the one.


Director Interview:

This interview is pretty standard and consists mostly of Gordon discussing the whole project and how it was all put together.

Lost and Found:

My favorite segment has Gordon return but also two restoration supervisors. Here we are shown what went into making this new transfer. Gordon talks about the original
video trims that were discovered on a work-print while the restoration guys talk about the condition of the work-print and the difficulty of splicing a work-print with an IP.


Interview with Composer:

Richard Band sits down to talk about the musical score of From Beyond. He points out the fact that the Re-animator score and this score are quite different. Also discussed
are some key musical notes and where the inspiration for these musical keys came from.


Photo Montage and Storyboards:

Also included in the set is a standard photo montage set to music and a collection of mulit-angle storyboard galleries. There is an introduction to the storyboards by Stuart Gordon who goes on to show off some of his original drawings.





Final Thoughts

From Beyond has been one of the most wanted DVDs of the last few years. It's one of those movies that took an extra while to finally make it to DVD and I'm happy to say
the wait was worth it; this is a fantatic transfer, uncut with new supplements. This is what fans have been waiting for!



DVD
Video: 9/10
Audio: 6.5/10
Extras: 7/10
Image
User avatar
thelostdragon
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 7059
Joined: 29 Oct 2004, 22:36
Location: Basin City

Post by thelostdragon »

Last Hurrah for Chivalry (Hong Kong - 1978) - R1US Dragon Dynasty
106:31 Mins (NTSC) - incl. the Dragon Dynasty and Fortune Star logos.
2.35:1 Anamorphic transfer.

Video:
The video quality varies from time to time. At times everything seems to be in focus, sharp and clear. And the next moment it is very soft and grainy. It is very colourful.

Audio:
- DD 5.1 Cantonese
- DD 5.1 English dub
- DD 2.0 Cantonese
- DD 2.0 Commentary

I compared the two Cantonese tracks and noticed that in some scenes the music seems either very quiet or possibly even non-existent with the 5.1 track.
Example is the scene at 07min 07sec.

Some scenes even have different music. Check out 11min 14 sec. The 5.1 track has a completely different tune playing that the original 2.0 track.

I suppose the 2.0 track is the original one after I compared it with my Deltamac version and hence I watched it this way.

Subtitles:
Subs are available in English and Spanish and there is also one set in English for the hard of hearing. Can't really say if they are literal translations or not, since my friend I usually ask is in China at the moment. But they don't seem dumbed down to me.

Special Features:
- The Bey Logan commentary track is exactly what you would expect. Informative and insightful.
- 09.38: Interview with Fung Hak-on (Cantonese with removable English subs).
- 10.57: Interview with Lee Hoi-san (Cantonese with removable English subs only).
- 10.51: Legendary Weapons of China Featurette. Bey Logan introduces the weapons used in the film and explains their backgrounds. Some Chinese guys demonstrate a few forms with these weapons as well. Logan demonstrates a few fighting strategies as well.
- 04.35: Original Theatrical Trailer (interlaced)
- 01.50: U.S. Promotional Trailer
Image
tom2681
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 5577
Joined: 25 Oct 2004, 15:18
Location: Where you'll never find me

Post by tom2681 »

The Sun Also Rises (China - 2007) - R3HK Joy Sales
116:05 Mins (NTSC)
2.30:1 Progressive Anamorphic transfer.

The video:
A very good transfer from Joy Sales.
Sharp close-ups, soft but detailed wide shots, deep blacks, good colours.
No obvious edge-enhancement or compression artefacts to complain about.
Apart from a few unintrusive white specks here and there (and a little bit of grain in dark scenes), this is an excellent transfer.

The sound:
There are two mandarin soundtracks:
- half-rate DTS.
- DD 5.1.

I only tried the DTS track.
It's a good mix with clear dialogue and excellent spatialization that really does justice to Joe Hisaishi's score.
Still, there is one very noticeable drop accompanied by a visible splice mark around the 00:52:00 mark. A bad edit, possibly.

The subtitles:
Almost perfect english subs. Very accurate, easy to read, not too fast, and with not too many spelling mistakes.
Some sentences are a bit clumsy and articles (a, an, the) are sometimes forgotten, but it's not distracting at all.
There are only two minor flaws worth mentioning:
- The subs are located in the bottom black bar, and while they are perfectly readable, they are a bit smaller than the subs we are used to. Could be an issue if you have a very small screen.
- They're a bit awkward when characters are having conversations. Characters' lines aren't preceded by hyphens ( - ), which makes it a little bit difficult to guess who's saying what. Not a big issue, thankfully.

The extras:
- There's a photo gallary (and that's not a spelling error on my part) with 10 blurry window-boxed pictures.
- 17.32: Making-of (chinese subtitles only).
- 29.06: Behind the Scene. 30 minutes of random behind the scenes footage (unsubtitled).
I used to be "the man who loves the movies you hate".
Now I'm just "that weird french guy with a cat avatar who comes to BnB once a year for no reason and then disappears again".
DangerousLeeHandsome
Flirting Scholar
Posts: 313
Joined: 16 Oct 2006, 02:27
Location: California, US

Post by DangerousLeeHandsome »

The Royal Tramp Collection (Hong Kong - 1992) - R1 US Dragon Dynasty
110:45, 98:18 Mins (NTSC) - incl. the Dragon Dynasty and Fortune Star logos.
1.85:1 Anamorphic transfer.

Video:
Royal Tramp is very grainy with digital noise scattered throughout and mild edge enhancements. Colors however are pretty solid and consistent. Could've really looked better though.

Royal tramp 2 isn't as grainy as part 1 but is a tad soft with a very weak color pallette. It does however fare better than part 1 in terms of noise and edge enhancements.


Audio:
- DD 5.1 Cantonese
- DD 5.1 English dub
- DD 2.0 Commentary

Both 5.1 tracks sounded pretty good to my ear. The only letdown, especially for purists, is that no mono track was included. When I asked Bey Logan about this, his answer was that the people they licenced it from "couldn't, wouldn't or just didn't" supply them with one.

Subtitles:
Subs are available in English, English SDH and Spanish. I can't clarify if the subs are accurate or not but atleast they get most of the characters' names right. Personally, if I were creating these subs, I would've taken some creative liberties since the jokes don't translate too well. Its a real inconvenience when you have to keep switching over to the commentary just so Bey Logan can explain what exactly just happened. Also onscreen text and road signs aren't translated.

Special Features:
Royal Tramp
- Commentary with Bey Logan - Another great track full of info and insight.
- Original Theatrical Trailer with English subs

Royal Tramp 2
- Commentary with Bey Logan - see above.
- Original Theatrical Trailer with English subs
- An Interview with writer/director Wong Jing (10:48) in Cantonese with English subs.

Overall. very light for a Dragon Dynasty DVD but getting 2 films for the price of one more than makes up for it.
Last edited by DangerousLeeHandsome on 08 Mar 2008, 19:37, edited 1 time in total.
RickyTheDragonSteamboat
Pedicab Driver
Posts: 265
Joined: 07 Dec 2006, 23:54

Post by RickyTheDragonSteamboat »

Crime Story (Hong Kong - 1993) - R1 US Dragon Dynasty
107:18 Mins (NTSC) - including the Dragon Dynasty and Fortune Star logos.
1.78:1 Progressive Anamorphic transfer.

Video:
A solid transfer, very film-like, with mild grain and speckling. The grain really contributes to the films dark and gritty atmosphere. Nice.

Audio:
- DD 5.1 Cantonese
- DD 2.0 Cantonese
- DD 5.1 English dub
- DD 2.0 Commentary

The 5.1 remixes sound natural without any real distracting new foley effects. The English dub seems to be the same one found on the Miramax dvd (minus the JC immitator). For purists, the original mono track is included. I've read reviews claiming it was downmixed, but thankfully, that is not the case.

Subtitles:
The subtitles are clear, well timed and easy to read with no errors that I could detect. Apparently, these are the old Media Asia subs found on the MegaStar dvd. I personally prefer the HKL subs since that was the first subtitled version I saw.

Special Features:
- Commentary with Director Kirk Wong & HK Film Expert Bey Logan. This is by far the best Bey Logan commentary I've listened to. It's quite entertaining to hear Kirk Wong speak so candidly of Jackie Chan. A very fun listen.
- "A Journey To The Underworld": An Interview with Director Kirk Wong (29:20)
- "From The Page to the Silver Screen": An Interview with writer Teddy Chen (12:14)
- Deleted Scenes w/ Play All (6:22)
--- "Can't Stop the Music!" (2:32)
--- "Racket Rage" (2:21)
--- "The Man in the Mirror" (1:29)
- Trailer Gallery:
--- Original Theatrical trailer
--- US Promotional Trailer

For a single disc release, this dvd is pretty stacked.
bradavon
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 24430
Joined: 27 Oct 2004, 19:30

Post by bradavon »

Thanks Ricky.

I've been considering picking up Crime Story. I hear it's inferior to the HK Joy Sales Remastered DVD but it sounds fine to me.
User avatar
Markgway
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 20195
Joined: 18 Feb 2005, 02:04

Post by Markgway »

The image on the Joy Sales is marginally better... but I'd love to know what Kirk Wong says about Jackie. Can you elaborate Ricky?
Image
RickyTheDragonSteamboat
Pedicab Driver
Posts: 265
Joined: 07 Dec 2006, 23:54

Post by RickyTheDragonSteamboat »

I loved how Kirk Wong laughs at the mention of Jackie's "family friendly" image. I found it hilarious.
RickyTheDragonSteamboat
Pedicab Driver
Posts: 265
Joined: 07 Dec 2006, 23:54

Post by RickyTheDragonSteamboat »

Once A Thief (Hong Kong - 1991) - R1 US Columbia Tristar Home Entertainment
108:06 Mins (NTSC) - including the Destination Films logo.
1.85:1 Anamorphic transfer.

Video:
This is, by far, the best looking version of Once a Thief I've ever seen. Print damage is almost non-existent with only a few specks here and there. Like most other versions, the film starts out very grainy but clears up quite well after the opening credits. Considering it utilizes the space of a single layered disc (a 4:3 version is also present on this DVD-9) the image looks very impressive.

Audio:
- DD 2.0 Cantonese
- DD 2.0 English dub

The DD 2.0 tracks sound clean and problem free. There are no audio drop-outs or flaws of any kind. No complaints.

Subtitles:
English, French and Spanish.

Standard yellow, easy to read subs. No dubtitles.

Special Features:
Bonus Trailers:
- Full Contact / Once A Thief
- Wasabi
- xXx
User avatar
Markgway
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 20195
Joined: 18 Feb 2005, 02:04

Post by Markgway »

Jackie's had more pussy than the RSPCA.
Image
DangerousLeeHandsome
Flirting Scholar
Posts: 313
Joined: 16 Oct 2006, 02:27
Location: California, US

Post by DangerousLeeHandsome »

Full Contact (Hong Kong - 1992) - R0 US Tai Seng
98:26 Mins (NTSC)
1.78:1 interlaced Anamorphic transfer.

Video:
Disappointing. Very dirty with tons of scratches and hairs. Doesn't come close to the R1 Sony.

Audio:
- DTS 5.1 Cantonese
- DD 5.1 Cantonese
- DD 5.1 Mandarin
- DD 5.1 English dub
- DD 2.0 Commentary

Pretty awful sounding remixes. All the gun shots are followed by annoying echoes. Everything echoes. Atleast it maintains the original theatrical score and not the workprint score found on HKL's and Sony's. No mono track is included.

Subtitles:
- Traditional Chinese
- English

No problems. Tai Seng often does a good job with their subs and this is another fine example.

Special Features:

- Audio Commentary by Hong Kong Cinema Expert Ric Meyers

I like Ric but this is not a great track. The guy runs out of things to say about 20 minutes into the film (I'm not joking!). Thankfully he isn't alone and Tai Seng marketing guy Frank (didn't get his last name) helps moves things along providing some insight and trivia about the film.

Bonus Trailers:
- Book and Sword
- Tai Chi Master
- Red Trousers
- Throwdown
- Treasure Hunt
- Province 77
- Yaowarat
- Iron Fist

Not very impressive.
User avatar
Markgway
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 20195
Joined: 18 Feb 2005, 02:04

Post by Markgway »

I like Ric but this is not a great track.
So you're the one? :?
Image
DangerousLeeHandsome
Flirting Scholar
Posts: 313
Joined: 16 Oct 2006, 02:27
Location: California, US

Post by DangerousLeeHandsome »

Ric's not that bad. But to be honest I haven't heard too many of his commentary tracks. I do however read his column in Inside Kung Fu magazine regularly.
User avatar
Markgway
Bruce Lee's Fist
Posts: 20195
Joined: 18 Feb 2005, 02:04

Post by Markgway »

DangerousLeeHandsome wrote:Ric's not that bad.
Apart from knowing eff all about the films he's commentating on....
Image
RickyTheDragonSteamboat
Pedicab Driver
Posts: 265
Joined: 07 Dec 2006, 23:54

Post by RickyTheDragonSteamboat »

Invisible Target (Hong Kong - 2007) - R1 US Dragon Dynasty
Aprox. 130:05 Mins (NTSC) - including the Dragon Dynasty and warning logos.
2.35:1 Progressive Anamorphic transfer.
Disc 1
Audio: Cantonese DTS 5.1, Cantonese Dolby 5.1, English Dolby 5.1
Subtitles: English, English HoH, Spanish
Special Features:
- Audio Commentary with Stars Jaycee Chan, Shawn Yue, Andy On and HK Cinema expert Bey Logan
- "Orchestrated Mayhem: The Making of Invisible Target" (24:57)
- Trailer Gallery: Teaser, trailer

Disc 2
Interview Gallery
- "Gen-X-Genius: Director Benny Chan" (22:27)
- "Like Father, Like Son: Star Jaycee Chan (18:51)
- "Licensed To Kill: Star Shawn Yue" (19:30)
- "Invincible Target: Lead Villain Jacky Wu Jing" (27:51)
- "Young and Dangerous: Co-star Philip Ng" (25:56)
- "Carte Blanche: Co-star Vincent Sze" (15:10)
- "The Ronin: Co-star Andy On" (20:19)
Deleted / Extended Scenes (w/ forced commentary by Director Benny Chan) Play All: 13:50
- "Pillar of the Community" (1:08)
- "Workin' the Room" (2:46)
- "Top Brass, Bottom Drawer" (3:08)
- "Look Who's Come to Dinner!" (2:16)
- "Come to the Coast, Have a Few Laughs!" (3:34)
- "Trojan Horse" (56sec)
Featurettes
- "Fight For Glory: Constructing the Action Sequences for Invisiblr Target" (18:56)
- Storyboard Comparison (18min)
- The Gala Premiere (10:16)