The Killer: R2DE vs R1 vs R2UK vs R2FR vs R2Nordic vs R3HK
Posted: 25 May 2006, 14:51
Note: The french HK Vidéo DVD contains both the theatrical cut and the extended taiwanese cut.
French subs are removable for the taiwanese cut (which contains burnt-in english subs).
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 1:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 1:
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 2:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 2:
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 3:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 3:
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 4:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 4:
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 5:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 5:
The french transfer is quite dirty, but it's supposed to be the sharpest.
Fox Lorber: Soft picture and contrast boosting from Hell.
Despite some cropping, the HKV is still the best (so far).
EDIT:
Wow. Even though the IVL is sharper in some shots, the HK Vidéo disc still has the upper hand in others.
Overall I'd say:
1. IVL
2. HK Vidéo
3. HKL
4. HK Vidéo Extended
4. Everything Else.
French subs are removable for the taiwanese cut (which contains burnt-in english subs).
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 1:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 1:
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 2:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 2:
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 3:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 3:
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 4:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 4:
R2DE:
R1 Fox Lorber:
HKL:
HKV HK 5:
R2Nordic:
IVL:
HKV EXT 5:
The french transfer is quite dirty, but it's supposed to be the sharpest.
Fox Lorber: Soft picture and contrast boosting from Hell.
Despite some cropping, the HKV is still the best (so far).
EDIT:
Wow. Even though the IVL is sharper in some shots, the HK Vidéo disc still has the upper hand in others.
Overall I'd say:
1. IVL
2. HK Vidéo
3. HKL
4. HK Vidéo Extended
4. Everything Else.
