EvaUnit02 wrote:Yi-Long wrote:and THEN work out where stunts and explosions and chases would be suitable, instead of writing a story around some stunt-setpieces and some chicks who cant act...
A lot of those HK movies that we like (eg Police Story) are made that way and I don't anyone complaining.
Erm, actually that's why I hated Hero and HoFD, their lack of decent writing, so nevermind.
Dude, just give up on Bond and watch the Jason Bourne movies, they're top-notch spy-thrillers IMO.
Actually, that's pretty much the main criticism Chan's movies get: Good beginning with a good action scene, then an hour of romantic comedy with some small action bits thrown in, and then a brilliant finale. Same thing with Ong Bak, TYG, and lots more azn movies. Weak story, great action. But in the case of these azn movies, the action-scenes makes up for the weak story, and in the last Bond movies, they don't.
Don't get me wrong, I like action as much as the next guy, but the Bond movies usually have pretty basic stuff in them: Big huge ass explosion and big noises and stuff, but it doesnt quite have the impact of say, an old-skool Jackie Chan fight, or a flying knee to the chest by Tony Yaa...
Also, I think people complain about the Bond movies, it's cause in the old ones it was a bit more about the whole setting, the story, the villain, and just Bond being Bond. I feel Connery did a great Bond, and both Moore and Brosnan kinda went over the top. Made Bond into a comicbook character, instead of human (which is why I'm also so fond of Dalton as Bond, as he portrayed a very human, yet lethal Bond)
You're dead-on about the Bourne movies, although part 2 for me was totally and utterly ruined by the director's insistence on using a shaky-cam and about 3 cuts a second, during the action scenes. Bourne Identity is classic though. That's how spy-movies should be made. Gritty, realistic, people with double/hidden agendas, etc etc. Too bad about those crappy shot action-scenes in pt 2 ...
I quite liked Hero btw. The first time I saw it I felt it was lacking a bit, but since then I've seen it once or twice more, and gotta say I liked it better after rewatching it. But it isn't a good action flick, and it isnt the best dramatic movie either.So it kinda falls flat on it's face between the genres it's trying to be, yet the sound and vision almost makes it into a whole new genre: eye-candy... and as such it does a great job.