Page 1 of 2

Spectre (2015)

Posted: 17 Sep 2015, 11:43
by Markgway
Figured I might as well start a thread for Bond 24.

Rated PG-13 for intense sequences of action and violence, some disturbing images, sensuality and language.

After SKYFALL I'm cautious about this one. I hope it's an improvement (especially in the script dept.).

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 21 Oct 2015, 18:49
by Markgway
Pre-cut version classified with a 12A certificate:

http://www.bbfc.co.uk/releases/spectre-film

@ 147:58 this is the longest entry in the 007 franchise.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 21 Oct 2015, 23:03
by grim_tales
Interesting.. I assume those cuts apply worldwide :? Although with Casino Royale (a similar case), the Oz release was uncut and the UK got an uncut release a little later.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 22 Oct 2015, 04:24
by HungFist
grim_tales wrote:Interesting.. I assume those cuts apply worldwide :?
Why would you expect them to apply worldwide? Didn't all the other Bond films that were cut in the UK always play uncut elsewhere (except the US sometimes had their own cut version)?

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 22 Oct 2015, 05:27
by Markgway
Dr. No (All BBFC cuts still apply)
From Russia with Love (All BBFC cuts still apply)
Goldfinger (All BBFC cuts still apply)
Thunderball (All BBFC cuts restored for VHS/DVD/BD)
You Only Live Twice (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)
On Her Majesty's Secret Service (BBFC addition still applies)
Diamonds Are Forever (BBFC cuts restored for VHS/DVD/BD*)
Live and Let Die (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)
The Man with the Golden Gun (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)
The Spy Who Loved Me (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)
Moonraker (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)
For Your Eyes Only (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)
Octopussy (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)
A View to a Kill (All BBFC cuts still apply)
The Living Daylights (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)
Licence to Kill (All BBFC and MPAA cuts restored for UE DVD/BD)
Goldeneye (Some BBFC and MPAA cuts still apply)
Tomorrow Never Dies (Some BBFC and MPAA cuts still apply)
The World Is Not Enough (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)
Die Another Day (Never cut by BBFC; MPAA cuts only to initial PG-13 version, later restored for UE DVD/BD)
Casino Royale (All BBFC cuts restored for BD; MPAA cuts only apply to PG-13 version)
Quantum of Solace (All distributor pre-cuts still apply)
Skyfall (Never cut by BBFC or MPAA)

International BDs always the same as UK/US editions (except Casino Royale).

Remains to be seen what happens with Spectre...

*Although there's still what appears to be a cut to a knee to the groin.
Could never get confirmation from the BBFC on that one and damned if I recall where I read it.
The obvious jump cut backs it up however.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 22 Oct 2015, 06:26
by HungFist
I didn't know so many old Bond films had been cut by BBFC. Thanks for the info.

I was mainly referring to License to Kill, Goldeneye and Casino Royale, which I believe played uncut in Continental Europe at least. Or am I mistaken?

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 22 Oct 2015, 15:00
by Markgway
HungFist wrote:I was mainly referring to License to Kill, Goldeneye and Casino Royale, which I believe played uncut in Continental Europe at least. Or am I mistaken?
Licence to Kill and Casino Royale were shown uncut in some countries.

Goldeneye, no.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 22 Oct 2015, 16:07
by HungFist
Markgway wrote: Goldeneye, no.
Are you sure about that? A Finnish film censorship site (in English) states the Finnish VHS from 1996 was uncut, while the later Finnish DVD releases were cut (the first dvd release was the cut German version; the later dvd was the cut BBFC version). The official Finnish film censorship office (in Finnish) states the Finnish VHS ran 125:18 (PAL) and the Finnish theatrical version (which they rated '16'... before and after an appeal) ran 130:30. If you convert 130:30 to PAL in becomes 125:17 - in other words, the same as the VHS which is supposed to be uncut. The Finnish DVD release from 1999 (which I believe should be the BBFC version) on the other hand is listed at 125:00, which is 17 seconds less than the VHS.

It's possible the running times listed above are not "accurate" (e.g. feature studio logos) but they do seem consistent with each other and with the claim of the VHS being uncut. Oddly enough, the running times reported by [urlhttp://www.bbfc.co.uk/releases/goldeneye-1995 ]BBFC[/url] are always about 1 minute shorter... perhaps they are listed without studio logos.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 23 Oct 2015, 02:25
by Markgway
It's complicated... but here's an excellent article which explains the various cuts in some detail.
http://www.melonfarmers.co.uk/bbfc_cuts_goldeneye.htm

I suspect the "uncut" Finnish VHS is simply the PG-13/international version now available everywhere on BD.

The truly uncut version has never been shown anywhere.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 23 Oct 2015, 03:43
by HungFist
I guess that would make sense.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 23 Oct 2015, 14:07
by Yi-Long
Spectre is getting reasonably positive reviews. I wasn't a big fan of Skyfall, while some reviews mention this falls short of that movie, so not sure what to make of that. Also some criticize the length (that's what she said...) and the ending.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 23 Oct 2015, 18:47
by Markgway
My expectations are tempered this time - after Skyfall, which contrary to most I found a disappointment.

I'll try to see it Tuesday.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 23 Oct 2015, 19:44
by saltysam
Markgway wrote:My expectations are tempered this time - after Skyfall, which contrary to most I found a disappointment.

I'll try to see it Tuesday.
I've never seen Skyfall but loved QOS...not a big Bond fan..but tbh Mark you dislike virtually everything so i would never use you as a review barometer for me anyway

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 24 Oct 2015, 00:38
by Markgway
saltysam wrote:Mark you dislike virtually everything so i would never use you as a review barometer for me anyway
Not true. I'm just not easy pleased or a sheep that follows trends. Do you read my quick takes? Plenty of films I like and give decent or better star ratings to.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 24 Oct 2015, 17:05
by saltysam
Markgway wrote:
saltysam wrote:Mark you dislike virtually everything so i would never use you as a review barometer for me anyway
Not true. I'm just not easy pleased or a sheep that follows trends. Do you read my quick takes? Plenty of films I like and give decent or better star ratings to.
Ypu lost me when you didn't like Fury Road ;)

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 25 Oct 2015, 02:10
by Yi-Long
saltysam wrote:
Markgway wrote:
saltysam wrote:Mark you dislike virtually everything so i would never use you as a review barometer for me anyway
Not true. I'm just not easy pleased or a sheep that follows trends. Do you read my quick takes? Plenty of films I like and give decent or better star ratings to.
Ypu lost me when you didn't like Fury Road ;)
He did love the movie Furry Broad though...

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 25 Oct 2015, 18:11
by Shingster
Yeah I think Mark's problem is that this isn't really a good forum for discussing gay porn, if it was he'd be churning out lots of positive reviews of the films he loves!

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 26 Oct 2015, 01:10
by Markgway
How did we get from Spectre to Shingster's gay porn fetish in four posts?

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 26 Oct 2015, 01:21
by Shingster
It took as many as four posts? I must be slipping!

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 26 Oct 2015, 14:53
by Yi-Long
Gawd.... I love gay porn... bless them.

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 26 Oct 2015, 17:30
by Markgway
Since we're on the subject... and Roger Moore brought it up... would you guys go to see a gay Bond?

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 26 Oct 2015, 18:25
by Shingster
Only if he gets to bum Jake Gyllenhaal in a tent!

TBH I always found the whole lady-killer aspect of Bond the least interesting thing, so I wouldn't care if he was gay or not. It'll never happen of course!

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 26 Oct 2015, 19:12
by Yi-Long
I would care, but only because it goes against the original character.

Kinda like I don't mind characters eating healthy, but I do mind when they suddenly turned Cookie Monster into Moderate Cookie Monster, who promotes a healthy, balanced diet.

I don't mind gay (lead) characters at all. I do mind when it's only used for scoring shock-value headlines and goes against an already established character.

Perhaps M could be gay?

I also find it amusing that Bond killing hundreds or thousands of people throughout the series is considered perfectly acceptable, yet the notion he could possibly kiss/fuck a dude is somehow controversial...

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 26 Oct 2015, 22:37
by grim_tales
Maybe Bond could have experimented? :D CR was a reboot after all, and it was heavily implied Le Chiffre was gay (imo). Bond's distrust of women could lead to him experimenting with guys, who knows?

Re: Spectre (2015)

Posted: 27 Oct 2015, 02:05
by Markgway
I think it was Skyfall's 'Silva' who was supposed to be gay and to whom Bond made his ambiguous remark.

Personally, I feel if they want to make movies with gay lead characters, that's fine. But not Bond. Bond is what he is - and one of those things is a beaver badgering sexist.